The 2025 PSL Awards have concluded, leaving a mix of discontent, surprise, and calls for change among players and fans alike. What was expected to be a night of joy and recognition has ignited debates about fairness and event presentation in the realm of South African football.
Rayners’ dissatisfaction reflects a wider disenchantment
Mamelodi Sundowns’ forward Iqraam Rayners, a key player in their record-breaking eighth consecutive league title, found himself conspicuously absent from the two most prestigious award categories this year, despite a stellar season. Rayners, who scored 14 goals in the Betway Premiership and provided nine assists, voiced his disappointment over being snubbed for both the Footballer of the Season and Players’ Player of the Season awards. “For me, I’m a bit disappointed because of what I did last season,” he expressed while questioning the selection criteria.
Rayners’ contributions were not limited to league matches, as he also made a significant impact in domestic cup competitions, adding four goals in the Carling Knockout Cup. Despite this, neither his impressive 27 direct goal contributions nor his role in Sundowns’ dominance were enough to secure him a slot alongside winners Lucas Ribeiro, Relebohile Mofokeng, and Keletso Makgalwa. These omissions have sparked conversations about the transparency and criteria of the awards.
A ceremony without soul
The awards event itself has been heavily criticized for its lackluster presentation. Attendees and viewers were met with a ceremony that felt more administrative than celebratory. Critiques highlight the absence of spontaneity and genuine emotion, as the ceremony appeared pre-recorded and emotionless. This removed the electrifying atmosphere that such a prestigious night should embody, making the event feel more like a chore than a celebration of football excellence.
The absence of an engaging format was evident, with speeches perceived as rehearsed and lacking individuality. Even Sports, Arts, and Culture Minister Gayton McKenzie’s announcement of the Footballer of the Season award lacked flair, underscoring the drab and uninspiring nature of the event.
Ribeiro’s triumph amid the gloom
Despite the criticism aimed at the event, it was a night of personal triumph for Lucas Ribeiro. The Mamelodi Sundowns attacker emerged as a leading figure, claiming four significant awards: Footballer of the Season, Players’ Player of the Season, Top Goalscorer, and Goal of the Season. His achievements were well-deserved, yet they were overshadowed by the broader dissatisfaction with the event’s presentation.
Ribeiro’s visible elation on social media contrasted starkly with the atmosphere of the official ceremony, highlighting the disconnect between personal celebration and public presentation.
Lessons for the future
With the PSL hailed as Africa’s premier football league, this year’s awards did little to reinforce that reputation. The absence of traditional elements like the red carpet and a lively audience made the ceremony feel like an afterthought. Additionally, the ongoing secrecy regarding prize money diminished the event’s sense of grandeur and transparency.
The players, fans, and organizers now face an opportunity for reflection and improvement. The PSL Awards should be an occasion that celebrates the talent and passion of South African footballers, resonating with both the players it honors and the fans who support them. To restore the magic, the league must prioritize authenticity, engagement, and transparency in future ceremonies.
As the dust settles on the 2025 PSL Awards, the hope is that constructive criticism will lead to renewed vigor and a more inclusive celebration of South African football in the years to come.
